Academic forced to rename 'hobbit' lecture

A Kiwi academic's lecture on diminutive primitive humans known as "hobbits" has been renamed, following legal pressure from the company which owns the rights to JRR Tolkien's creations.

Victoria University earth scientist Brent Alloway had planned to call the free public lecture on the one-metre-tall human species Homo floresiensis "The Other Hobbit".

But the title had to be scrapped after lawyers representing Saul Zaentz Company/Middle-earth Enterprises - which owns some rights to The Hobbit books - objected that it was not possible to allow generic use of the term "hobbit".

The lecture next month has since been renamed, "A newly discovered species of Little People - unravelling the legend behind Homo floresiensis".

The event at Wellington's Te Papa museum had been timed to coincide with the release of the first film in Peter Jackson's Hobbit trilogy.

It will feature two of the principal archaeologists involved in the discovery in 2003 of Homo floresiensis on the Indonesian island of Flores.

Dr Alloway, who has been been examining volcanic deposits associated with stone artefacts and fossil remains on the island, said the controversy surrounding the name was disappointing.

"I really want to move on from the controversy about not being able to use The Hobbit. I kind of went into this rather naively, not really knowing about these name propriety trademarks.

"All I want to deliver is something interesting to the New Zealand public, and at a time when everybody is really getting into the celebratory sense of Peter Jackson's movie, which is going to be quite a classic I'd imagine."

Homo floresiensis was nicknamed the "hobbit" because it stood just over one metre tall, had large feet and was capable of undertaking complex activities.

Dr Alloway said some people might view the planned title of the lecture as being "rather opportunistic", but he did not want to dwell on the stir it had caused.

He said the lecture would give a fascinating account of a new human species which had "turned our ancestral origins completely on its head".

"It's a new dimension to our ancestral roots which we're only just starting to really begin to understand."

Dr Alloway has travelled Flores twice this year to study issues like whether the island's volcanic nature had helped the species expand.

"For instance, if you had a volcanic eruption wiping out the forest and creating a grassland where large animals can graze, it presents opportunities for Homo floresiensis to more easily hunt large animals."

Dr Alloway was also studying the volcanic ash layers to trace distribution and changes in the environment over time.

He said one of his highlights had been finding a stone artefact that was a million-years-old, and then finding another even older artefact - to the surprise of the archaeologists.

"I felt at the time that everything I've ever done in my career had led me to that point, and it was a fabulous feeling - just to be able to go to a place like Flores from New Zealand."

The archaeologists to speak at the lecture are Professor Mike Morwood, from the University of Wollongong in Australia, and Thomas Sutikna, from Pusat Arkeologi Nasional in Indonesia.

They will present original artefacts and a full-size replica skeleton.

Add a Comment