So far, so good for Razor’s men

Will Jordan looks for support during the first test between the All Blacks and France at Forsyth Barr Stadium in Dunedin on July 5. Photo: Peter McIntosh

You can divide the 2025 All Blacks season into three parts: the French series, the Rugby Championship and the end-of-year tour. Part one is in the books, so here is Hayden Meikle with a quick summary.

Glass half full

1 The All Blacks swept the series. Everyone expected that, of course, as France sent a team on tour minus so many leading players. But you can only beat who is put in front of you, and the All Blacks got the job done. Had they lost one of the tests, well, that would have led to an extremely interesting series postmortem.

2 There were glimpses of . . . something. While the first and third tests were relatively underwhelming, the performance in the second was pretty impressive in patches. Razor’s recruits clearly have a way to go, but there are signs this team possesses a bit more spark than last year.

3 Goal kicking was excellent, highlighted by Beauden Barrett’s perfect night off the tee in Wellington. Defence and lineout drives (yawn) win World Cups, but goal kicking is not far behind.

4 New blood. Six new All Blacks have joined the club, and all contributed in some way. More on that below.

Glass half empty

1 Injuries. By my count, no fewer than 10 of the original squad for the series missed some or all of the action with various knocks.

Codie Taylor runs at the French defence during the first test. Photo: Peter McIntosh

2 Aerial skills lacking. The French regularly peppered the All Blacks with high up-and-unders, and the All Blacks did not always deal with them well. Big improvements needed.

3 Glimpses, yes, but there were no real earth-shattering developments around how the All Blacks played. The season is about to get a lot harder, and can we really say they are that much advanced from this point last season?

4 Wing crisis. Will Jordan is a world-class winger but now clearly established as Scott Robertson’s favourite fullback. Nobody really knows who out of Sevu Reece, Caleb Clarke, Emoni Narawa and no-longer-a-midfielder Rieko Ioane should be starting on the left and right. Perhaps Leicester Fainga’anuku — back from France — trumps them all.

Players who shone

1 Will Jordan just does what he does. Now has 42 tries in 44 tests. Ridiculous.

2 Ardie Savea, well, just does what he does. A relentless force at No 8 or No 7, and stand-in captain to boot.

3 Fabian Holland. More on him below.

4 Beauden Barrett. Played particularly well in the Wellington test. Assured starter at first five for the immediate future — perhaps until Robertson gets his beloved Richie Mo’unga back.

Fabian Holland gives the thumbs up at Forsyth Barr Stadium. Photo: Peter McIntosh

5 The whole front row. Ethan de Groot had a very good series, Codie Taylor continues to set a high standard, and the other big boppers all did well.

Jury is out

1 Rieko Ioane — appears his centre days are done, but is he still good enough as a starting winger?

2 Damian McKenzie — still has that spark, but is his future exclusively as an impact player?

3 Samipeni Finau — give him a few more tests to keep progressing or stick with Tupou Vaa’i?

Rookie watch

A+ Fabian Holland took to test rugby like a Dutch to water, as we suspected he would. Played every minute. Not sure how he misses out on a place in the strongest All Blacks XV now.

B Du’Plessis Kirifi is just a ball of energy. Clearly now the leading back-up to Savea on the side of the scrum.

Tupou Vaa’i seeks to offload during the first test. Photo: Peter McIntosh

B- Christian Lio-Willie came from nowhere to start the first two tests and did a solid job. Will battle for time when Wallace Sititi becomes available.

C Timoci Tavatavanawai got 28min in the second test and just 11min in the third. Offers something completely different and we need to see more of him.

C- Ollie Norris had a couple of solid shifts off the bench in the first two tests.

D Brodie McAlister was running at an F after his lineout throwing fell apart on debut. Then he scored a cracking try. Unlikely to play again much this year, you would think.

The questions

1 If that was France B, how good would France A have been? Would the All Blacks have swept them?

2 Is World Rugby actually going to do anything about the farcical situation of a major nation devaluing a test series by leaving their best players behind?

3 When Scott Barrett returns, um, is there actually a place for him in the starting XV?

4 If so, is Jordan, Reece, Lienert-Brown, J Barrett, Fainga’anuku, B Barrett, Roigard, Sititi, Savea, Vaa’i, Holland, S Barrett, Lomax, Taylor and Williams that XV? With Taukei’aho, de Groot, Newell, Finau, Kirifi, Hotham, Tavatavanawai and McKenzie on the bench?