Homeowners may eventually need to abandon their cribs in Coopers Creek — a small, quirky settlement surrounded by bush within Sandy Point Domain.
On Tuesday, councillors heard from a range of people who supported the unconventional settlement and the residents’ unique traditions.
In September, councillors voted to replace those licences with a single 21-year licence — including rights of renewal to a maximum of 35 years — in hopes it would put an end to the anomaly.
That approach was consulted on as part of the domain’s management plan, which went to a hearing this week.
Proceedings began with a submission from local historian and former-councillor Lloyd Esler, who hoped there was a long-term future for villagers.
"I’m pleased that the council has decided to extend their mandate to stay on.
"[I’m] disappointed in the way that it’s not indefinite, because they’re continuing a very useful tradition."
Mr Esler’s written submission said the council had flexibility over the interpretation of rules.
He felt having residents in the area afforded security which outweighed any non-compliance.
Kath and Brian McDonagh also believed the village should exist in perpetuity, saying it was possible if the council amended its ten-year management plan.
"That may seem radical to some, however it will eliminate any need for revocation or freehold, not to mention the years-long battles between council and villagers that wear everyone down," Mrs McDonagh said.
The pair felt the council prioritised conservation over people when it came to the domain.
Kerry Hapuku and Bob McMurdo also submitted in unison, saying the tenure options preferred by villagers had not been considered.
They pointed out in their written submission that the council had created the "dilemma" by granting reserve status to the domain after the village had already been built.
At the September meeting, mana whenua representative Evelyn Cook said leaseholders should be aware of limitations to living there.
Ms Cook said mana whenua had a vested interest in the area, and was concerned issuing a longer lease with a right of renewal was a decision stretching beyond one generation.
There are 17 leaseholders at Coopers Creek.
A total of 51 submissions were received during the consultation process which ran from November 9 to January 31.
Topics raised included vehicle access, dog walking, horse trekking and a visitor centre.
The recommendations of the hearings panel will return to council for either approval or rejection.
Final sign-off for the council’s management plan is required from the Minister of Conservation.
• LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
