WARNING: This article discusses suicide and may be distressing.
A man who was "angry, spiteful, humiliated and running out of options". This is how John Beckenridge has been described by a psychologist who believes the stepfather committed a murder-suicide.
"It was like he possessed Mike as a son rather than loved Mike as a son," the psychologist told the Coroner’s hearing on Wednesday.
A week later, Beckenridge’s 4WD Volkswagen Touareg went off the cliff near Curio Bay, in Southland. But when police recovered the vehicle there were no signs of any bodies and the two have been missing since.
However, Mike’s mother Fiona Lu is convinced her son is alive and that her former partner, Beckenridge, staged the pair’s death after she moved Mike from Beckenridge’s Queenstown home to Invercargill with her new partner, Peter Russell.
Now, Coroner Marcus Elliot is looking into the case at the Christchurch District Court to consider whether it is likely the pair are dead.
A ‘bleak future’
On Wednesday, the court heard from a registered psychologist who took a deep dive into the Beckenridge case to provide his expert opinion to police.
The psychologist, who cannot be named, said Beckenridge struck him as an orderly person who was very "controlling and coercive" particularly towards intimate partners.
"He was used to winning. If you didn’t give him something, things would turn drastic," the professional said.
Leading up to the disappearance, Beckenridge was nearing rock bottom. Mike was permanently in the care of Lu and Beckenridge had turned to "last resort thinking", the psychologist said, adding the care arrangement was a "tipping point".
"He is looking at a bleak, meaningless future without Mike in it."
The psychologist opined Beckenridge believed he was rescuing Mike from an "unhappy situation".
Beckenridge blamed Lu for the separation and wanted revenge after she entered a new relationship with Russell, the psychologist said.
"He wanted care and control of Mike and wanted to deprive Fiona of that."
While the psychologist accepted there was "a possibility" Beckenridge and Mike were still alive, he believed the probability of this was lower than the probability of murder-suicide.
"His [Beckenridge] state of mind is consistent with committing murder-suicide, I believe," the psychologist said.
A mother’s hope
In a statement read to the court, Lu said she firmly believed Beckenridge had the skill and ability to survive and even without Mike, he would not be suicidal.
She said Mike did not want to die and that he was "brainwashed" by his stepfather.
"I miss my son and I think about him every day. I believe Mike will come back to me one day."
She said Beckenridge had taken her son "out of hatred" towards her.
The Minecraft message
Earlier in the day, the court heard evidence that Mike’s best friend believed Mike had reached out to him eight months after he disappeared.
The claimed communication was through the online game Minecraft which the pair previously played together, detective Jeremy Dix, who carried out an extensive investigation into the Beckenridges’ whereabouts and had spoken with the boy, told the court.
The friend said he was messaged by an unknown user on the platform in November 2015 referencing a username only the two knew about. He believed it was Mike.
The boy tried to contact the user but they had logged off. He said Mike had come up with the username in 2014 when he was helping set up his account, warning his friend to not use his real name to avoid bullying online.
"Mike was pretty good at sticking up for himself online and could be brutal at putting people down," Dix said, quoting the boy.
The boy’s mother had since purchased a new game for him, the same game Mike had started playing before he disappeared.
It was hoped that Mike would contact his friend through the platform but this has not happened.
However, Dix believed the boy was "mistaken" and said there was a possibility Mike could have mentioned the username to another person without the friend knowing.
Dix also said the boy, who was around 14 at the time he spoke to police, had changed some details of his evidence.
The detective had made multiple inquiries with various gaming platforms and software, requesting information on any usernames that could be associated with Mike, but those inquiries were unable to be progressed.
Last week, at the outset of the inquest, Lisa Preston KC outlined the case. She said Beckenridge met Mike’s mother, who is from China, in 2006. Lu’s parents were raising Mike at the time.
The pair later moved with Mike to Queenstown. Their relationship broke down in 2014. Shortly after that, Lu moved to Invercargill.
In February 2015, the Queenstown Family Court made an order that Lu should have care of Mike.
Mike was unhappy to be taken away from his stepfather and was secretly communicating with him by email, pleading for Beckenridge to come to take him away from his mother and her partner.
Mike told Beckenridge he was misbehaving so he could be sent back to live with his stepfather. He also called the police on one occasion, saying his mother had assaulted him in the hope he would be sent back to Queenstown.
On March 20, Beckenridge’s friends began receiving "concerning" texts from him, stating the "Gestapo" was after him and Mike, and they would soon get on the "Midnight Express" for departure.
On March 22, items belonging to the Beckenridges such as clothes and car parts washed ashore in the Curio Bay area. Soon after, Beckenridge’s vehicle was found at the bottom of the cliff.
The police national dive squad was able to investigate the wreckage on March 29 but it wasn’t until May 6 that the vehicle could be recovered. No bodies were found.
To date, police have had 60 suspected sightings of the Beckenridges or their vehicle, some of which have been deemed unlikely or eliminated.
Information about possible sightings continues to be reported from within New Zealand and from Kiwis overseas.
The hearing continues.
- Emily Moorhouse, Open Justice reporter
SUICIDE AND DEPRESSION
Where to get help:
• Lifeline: 0800 543 354 (available 24/7)
• Suicide Crisis Helpline: 0508 828 865 (0508 TAUTOKO (available 24/7)
• Youth services: (06) 3555 906
• Youthline: 0800 376 633
• What's Up: 0800 942 8787 (11am to11pm)
• Depression helpline: 0800 111 757 (available 24/7)
• Rainbow Youth: (09) 376 4155
• Helpline: 1737
If it is an emergency and you feel like you or someone else is at risk, call 111.
