The Wanaka Community Board decided at a meeting this week a proposal for an 18-hole disc golf course at Lismore Park should go out for community consultation.
Frisbee golf club spokesman Martin Galley told the Otago Daily Times yesterday he had been surprised at the level of opposition to the proposal when it went before the community board.
"This park is underutilised. It is a massive area, which can be shared by all sorts of groups," he said.
Former Wanaka board member Graham Dickson said disc golf should be played elsewhere.
The Lismore Park management plan protects passive recreation, which is incompatible with Frisbee golf.
The Wanaka Residents Association representative said unsuspecting park-users would be susceptible to "high-speed flying missiles" and other "inaccuracies" common to golf.
He called for a more suitable park to be found.
After taking advice from parks manager Gordon Bailey and seeking information from Mr Galley, the board decided the proposal did not comply with the management plan and it should be notified for public submissions.
The board was also split on whether to support the activity or reduce the proposed course from 18 holes to nine holes.
A hearing panel to consider public submissions has been appointed, comprising Jude Battson, Ken Copland and Mike O'Connor.