In May, the Otago Daily Times reported that after nine frustrating years of work by locals trying to save the 1870 wooden church, designed by Robert Lawson, it would be put up for sale.
Residents said the Kakanui Church, now on the market, was a well-loved community landmark, and they had been keen to save it, including by previously offering to provide funds to help with its conservation maintenance.
One Agency, of Oamaru, is selling the property and says, on its internet site, "this masterpiece is now looking for new owners to bring her back to her former glory".
When approached for comment, One Agency saleswoman Kelli Millmine said on Monday the property was still "up for sale" but the situation had become "very complex", and she could not comment further. She suggested the ODT sought an update in about a week.
St Paul's Maheno-Otepopo Presbyterian Church minister Rev Rose Luxford confirmed the church was for sale, and referred the ODT to the parish property committee.
"I hope it's bought by someone who cares for its heritage ... values," Mr Chetwin said.
"Something definite happening would be a very good thing."
The building had long been deteriorating, and he would have no objection if someone bought it to restore it and use it as a home.
Such a sale in Kakanui would save an important local landmark, and the only sizeable building in the area surviving from the 19th century pioneer era, he said.
Dunedin resident David McClea who grew up in Kakanui and worshipped at the church for many years, said he remained hopeful that a sale could lead to the building being saved and restored.
