Andrew Ronald Macmillan (56) was jailed for life in 1989 after murdering 17-year-old Jayne McLellan, whose body was found in the Kaikorai Stream.
At a hearing in October, the Parole Board outlined the Waikeria Prison inmate’s three-page criminal history, which included convictions while on release after the murder.
Macmillan was paroled twice in 2020 but lasted only months before being charged with possessing cannabis and a weapon, which landed him back behind bars.
At his most recent hearing, the board heard the prisoner had potential accommodation lined up this month, but chairman Sir Ron Young questioned its suitability.
"We do not think the kind of oversight and support ... is adequate for Mr MacMillan’s risk.
"What is of significance is he has been recalled to prison for murder. He has a number of convictions on parole. He has a past history of criminal activity prior to the murder and his reintegrative need is significant," Sir Ron said.
Macmillan’s behaviour had improved since his last parole hearing in April and he was reported to be making "good progress" with one-on-one counselling.
A psychologist recommended the minimum-security prisoner progress through self-care units at the prison to eventually working outside the wire.
Macmillan had done all rehabilitative treatment asked of him.
Sir Ron said the killer was soon to be interviewed for "release to work" — a scheme which allowed inmates to do paid employment in the community with a view to obtaining employment when they were released.
Macmillan was assessed as presenting a low to moderate risk of reoffending.
He will see the Parole Board again in July 2023.
