Star Wars games, however, are a completely different story - most of them, and I have thought about this quite a bit, are decidedly average - the original arcade game was great and a couple of the old PC games were good, but on consoles they have mostly been disappointing.
Kinect Star Wars
For: Xbox 360 + Kinect
From: Lucasarts
3 stars (out of 5)
So I loaded up Kinect Star Wars with a mixture of excitement and apprehension, especially as I knew Lucasarts had put in a dancing game ...
The game is essentially a group of minigames based around the Star Wars universe. It all begins with a comedy introduction by the games hosts C-3P0 and everyone's favourite dustbin, R2-D2.
You then get to choose from Jedi Destiny: Dark Side Rising, Podracing, Rancor Rampage, Galactic Dance Off and Duels of Fate.
And then there's Galactic Dance Off.
Dancing? In a Star Wars game?
Technically, I should hate it. And I did. Until I played it, and it is actually not bad, provided you can ignore the fact you are in a dance-off with Han Solo, or that the band is, in fact, using dodgy lyrics to well-known songs ... the jury is still out though.
If I tried I could be really scathing about this game - but that would be based on my feelings towards the Star Wars franchise. If I forget about that (meaning I accept the fact that no console game is ever going to make me a Jedi and give me a real light sabre) and judge it on what Kinect games are supposed to be - which is fun - then it's great.
It has it's flaws, but if you love the crazy arm-waving world that is Kinect gaming you will definitely enjoy this.
- By Simon Kemp