Hawkes Bay's Badger were one of four bands to warm the crowd at last week's concert in Napier for the touring 72-year-old.
Martin Good, Badger's bass player, told Hawkes Bay Today their set was nipped in the bud when Sir Elton came out of his dressing room saying, "What's that racket?".
"After we got off, the stage manager came up to us and said, 'Elton's not happy'," Good said.
"I think it was probably the drums more than anything that was possibly annoying him while he was trying to sleep."
Now the four-piece outfit have found themselves cut from the second show.
"We've had to re-adjust the schedule for the day and unfortunately can't fit them in," Mission Concert manager Garry Craft said.
The pair of concerts are being held at Mission Estate, a picturesque winery on New Zealand's east coast.
While the schedule has been re-arranged for Saturday's show, gates will open as normal and Sir Elton is still due to go on stage at the same time.
The only rearrangement is that the four warm-up acts have been condensed to three, with Badger on the outer.
"We'd like to take this opportunity to thank The Mission for having us back again last Thursday," the band posted on its Facebook page.
"Always a pleasure and we look forward to finding out who next years big act is soon."
Sir Elton's appearances in Napier come either side of a dash across the Pacific to appear at the Oscars.
The Englishman won the Academy Award for Best Song for the second time in his career, picking up the award for (I'm Gonna) Love Me Again from the film Rocketman, a biopic on Sir Elton's own life.
He also won the prize in 1995 for Can You Feel The Love Tonight, one of three nominated songs from animated classic The Lion King.
Sir Elton's Farewell Yellow Brick Road tour continues to Auckland and Australia later this month as part of his long-running final tour. He played at Dunedin's Forsyth Barr Stadium last week.
